The mad, bad, batsh*t duo of Nic and Jen are back for season 2 of ‘Am I Being Unreasonable?’

On-screen British oddness has its own flavour that is utterly addictive for those inclined towards dark, sardonic humour.

Am I Being Unreasonable Season 2

L-R: Nic (Daisy May Cooper) and Jen (Selin Hizli). Credit: BBC/Boffola Pictures

Think of the comically ill-fated Gallagher family in Shameless, the absurd circumstances that beset Vinnie and his mates in , or the perfect actorly duet between Olivia Colman and Julian Barrett as Deborah and Maurice in Flowers. Whether it's deeply depressed protagonists, poverty-stricken desperados, or couples battling to keep their family from destruction, there are still gallons of deep chuckles to be found in the resonating pains of living. As the old saying goes, if you don't laugh, you'll cry (a lot).
In that spirit, we welcome back Am I Being Unreasonable? for a second season. The dynamics between Jen and Nic are the heart of this series. Everyone has had that friend who you love to bits, but they're also kind of hopeless. The hilarity of Nic’s downbeat hubby Dan and poor son Ollie are just as captivating as the murder plot that may blow everyone's life apart.

If there was any trace of doubt that Daisy May Cooper and Selin Hizli could bring those zinger one-liners – and Cooper’s priceless facial expressions - while kneading thriller, comedy and drama into concise episodes, that doubt would be thoroughly blitzed by season 2.

As a recap, Nic (Cooper) was thrown out of her and Dan’s house for conducting an affair with her husband's late brother, Alex, and discovered - too late - that her best friend, Jen (Hizli), records their private conversations. Importantly, Alex was killed by - that's right! - Nic. However, this is all revealed in flashbacks, both real and illusory, so for viewers with memories like Swiss cheese (full of holes, that is), you won't be left in a state of confusion.
Am I Being Unreasonable Season 2
L-R: Jen (Selin Hizli) and Nic (Daisy May Cooper). Source: BBC / Boffola Pictures
Naturally, Nic's crime did not go unwitnessed. A couple that could attest to how Alex met his premature demise are - to say the least - a hiccup for Nic and her campaign to cover up the murder. This is genuinely thrilling - viewers can be forgiven for hovering their fingers over the "next" button as hearts race in fear our beloved murderer will be found out. Although she's a mediocre murderer, Nic is a somewhat more successful mother. For all his faults, including a possibly inherited murderous streak, her son Ollie (BAFTA-winning Lenny Rush) is more stable than his mother. His poker-faced delivery of some absolutely flooring lines, or pulling some epic tantrums, will have viewers wondering how Nic went so long without killing anyone.

Poor Jen faces a challenging dilemma that pales in comparison to Nic's murder-cover-up issues, though it keeps her up at night. Has her new friend murdered someone, and is she complicit? Where do her loyalties lie?

Let's not forget Dan, either. Dustin Demri-Burns veers between hard-done-by hubby and rotten, neglectful ratbag. Some of the most entertaining conversations in this series are between Nic and Dan, verbally battling in the way that only people who really love - and really hate - each other can.
Am I Being Unreasonable Season 2
L-R: Ollie (Lenny Rush) and Nic (Daisy May Cooper). Credit: BBC/Boffola Pictures
This is the art of Cooper and Hizli's script. Nic, Dan, Jen, Ollie and Alex should be loathsome - and perhaps they are from a distance - but their humility, their genuine desire to find a way to live peacefully, is so relatable. And, in witnessing the way Nic and Jen traverse a borderline between full-on friendship and utter frenemies, there's a bristling tension most adult women can relate to. This is a competitive world, and there's so many minor and major misunderstandings to traverse daily. For every woman who has had a friendship mirroring Rachel and Monica in Friends, there's likely a zillion more who have had a Nic and Jen (can I trust her? Is she the greatest thing since sliced bread?) situation.

For fans of previous Cooper outing This Country, fear not! In this season, there is more than a nod and wink to Kerry and Kurtan in that series. And like This Country, Am I Being Unreasonable? fully deserves to be lauded amongst the best British dark comedies of all time. Slotted in there with Nighty Night, Shameless, Flowers, The League of Gentlemen, In The Loop, and The Young Ones, this is unmissable viewing for anyone who likes to laugh, cry, bemoan the state of the world, and fall in love with all the flawed, fabulous creatures on screen.

Two seasons of Am I Being Unreasonable? are streaming now at SBS On Demand.

Stream free On Demand

Thumbnail of Am I Being Unreasonable?

Am I Being Unreasonable?

series • 
comedy
MA15+
series • 
comedy
MA15+

Share
4 min read
Published 13 March 2025 1:52pm
By Cat Woods
Source: SBS

Share this with family and friends